1370 Wilbur Avenue — Garage Rebuild

06 · Structural Engineering

Preliminary engineering study. Not a construction document. No connection, base plate, anchor or foundation is designed or checked. Nothing here may be built from until a California-licensed structural engineer has reviewed, signed and sealed the design.

Interactive model

Open the frame model →

Every member extruded at its actual cross-section, so relative sizes are readable. Colour switches between how hard each member is working and what governs it. Checkboxes toggle the existing garage walls and roof, the new frame, the pre-demolition stage, and the loft layout.

Frame plan → — every member named and dimensioned, openings hatched.

STR-008 cost reduction study (markdown) →

STR-008: Frame cost reduction study

Revision 3 · 2026-09-19 · Status: Draft

Scheme: BEAM-001, frame-20260920.01-beam-scheme Live load: 100 psf (DEC-014) · Wind: 96 mph, Exposure C Code: 2022 CBC / ASCE 7-16 · Software: PyNite 3.2.0, COMPAS 2.15.1

The stored COMPAS model is the design. The owner revisions — the solar slope seated on B-SO, BE.upper, the east side rebuilt in wood, the stairwell moved south, BWI-2/BWI-3 merged, the N-M2 post and the redundant bracing — are baked into it and listed in its revisions key, with baked_from naming the model they started from. Opening the file gives the frame as drawn here, not its starting point.

The finding that reorders everything else

Optimising this frame for weight optimises the cheapest thing in it.

Cost driverRate
Steel material$0.77–0.94/lb — 1,000 lb is worth about $850
Shop fitting and welding$16–39 per joint
Field-bolted connections$40–80 each
Erection, per piece$55–95
Procurement$150–400 per distinct section
Shop fabrication minimum$10,000–18,000 as a job charge

The quantities that move money are pieces, joints and distinct sections — not pounds. Removing a member deletes its joints, its handling and its erection; thinning a member’s wall deletes none of those.

Verified package

As drawnRecommendedChange
Steel9,718 lb8,047 lb−1,671 lb
Pieces7358−15
Fitted joints135104−31
Distinct sections116−5
Cost$23,028–41,596$18,416–32,840−$6,684
Worst utilisation0.980.777—
Wind driftH/464H/434—
Deflection violations00—

Every option was re-solved against each governing load combination and checked for strength, span deflection and wind drift before being counted.

Section palette

Collapsing to one section per structural role is the cheapest change available — it adds steel and saves money, and the frame gets safer doing it.

RoleSection
ColumnsHSS5×5×1/4
TrussHSS3×3×1/8
Clerestory and bracingHSS2-1/2×2-1/2×1/8
RaftersHSS2×2×1/8

No floor joist can be deleted

The joists carry the deck, and the deck is not in the structural model. Tested one at a time against the 23/32 in. OSB span of 24 in., measured across each deck including out to its framed edges: at 15.4 in. centres, removing one joist doubles the span to about 31 in. There is no deletion that lands inside 24 in.

An earlier revision of this study proposed deleting 33 of 54 joists. That was a defect in the deck-span check, not a finding — it would have left one shelf with no framing at all and a 128 in. gap in a loft bay. The frame solver never objected, because there are no plates in the model: with the joists gone the tributary machinery handed the floor load straight to the beams, and the beams could carry it.

That is the standing limitation of this whole study. A bare frame analysis cannot tell whether there is anything left for the sheathing to sit on.

Owner revisions carried

Construction sequencing

51 members can be erected before the existing roof comes off, with 61 waiting. Four members penetrate the existing eave and need a hole rather than an opening: BWI-1, BWI-2, BWI-3 and S3.

What still needs engineering

Limits

Gravity, wind and a seismic screening check only. Costs are parametric estimates on this project’s own rates, not quotations; the differences between options are more reliable than the totals. Every reduction is conditional on the 100 psf live load of DEC-014 and the concentrated equipment loads of ASM-011, which remain open.